Short Rib Cottage Pie

Photo by Michael Piazza / Styled by Catrine Kelty

(Inspired by the Warren Tavern’s Famous Shepherd’s Pie)

The Warren Tavern keeps its Shepherd’s Pie recipe a closely guarded secret, so we’ve re-created it here for you from memory. It’s really more of a cottage pie, since it’s made with beef and not lamb, but what makes the Tavern’s version so special is the use of lush short ribs instead of the traditional minced meat. This is a rich dish—luxe even—and would be an easy, make-ahead holiday supper or New Year’s Day lunch, alongside a tall brown ale. Served at the Warren Tavern topped with a crown of fried onions and a side salad, we like to serve ours with sharply dressed bitter greens, whole parsley leaves and pickled shallots.

Serves 6

FOR THE BRAISED RIBS:
6 meaty bone-in beef short ribs, each about 12–14 ounces (4½–5 pounds total)
kosher salt and freshly ground black pepper
granulated garlic
2 teaspoons minced fresh thyme leaves
1 tablespoon extra virgin olive oil
2 cups diced carrots
2 cups diced celery
3 cups sliced yellow onion
4 cloves garlic, crushed and chopped
pinch chili flakes, optional
2 tablespoons organic tomato paste
2 cups hearty red wine
2 cups rich chicken or beef stock
2 bay leaves, 1 sprig rosemary, small bunch thyme tied together in a bundle
1 teaspoon balsamic vinegar, or to taste 1
teaspoon Worcestershire sauce, or to taste

FOR THE TOPPING, ASSEMBLY AND SERVING:
2 cups frozen peas
3 pounds Yukon Gold potatoes, peeled and quartered
3 cloves garlic, crushed
1½ cups whole milk or half-and-half
1 stick unsalted butter, room temperature, plus more for buttering small casserole dishes
1 bay leaf
1 sprig fresh thyme
kosher salt and freshly ground black pepper
4 ounces grated sharp Vermont cheddar cheese, divided
4 cups arugula or other bitter greens
2 cups flat leaf Italian parsley leaves
¹/₃ cup quick pickled shallots (shallot rings soaked in red wine vinegar with a pinch of salt and sugar, set aside for 30 minutes)
¼ cup
Garlicky-Dijon Vinaigrette

Preheat oven to 325°F. To make the braised beef, season each short rib generously with salt and pepper, sprinkle lightly with granulated garlic and rub with the minced thyme. Set aside to “cure” for about 30 minutes at room temperature.

When the beef has absorbed the salt, heat a large casserole over medium-high and add the olive oil. Sear the ribs on all sides until golden brown, working in batches if needed. Set aside on a plate to rest.

When all the beef is browned and resting, pour off all but 1 tablespoon of the fat from the casserole and add the carrots, celery and onion. Season with salt and pepper and sauté until lightly browned and softened. Add the crushed garlic, chili flakes (if using) and tomato paste. Cook, stirring, about 3–4 minutes or until the tomato paste has turned a deep russet red. Pour in the wine and stock, add the bundle of herbs and bring to a boil; nestle the short ribs back into the liquid along with any collected juices. Reduce heat to a simmer; crumple and uncrumple a sheet of parchment paper and nestle it on top of the stew, then cover with a lid. Place the covered casserole in the oven and braise until the meat pulls away from the bones, about 3½ to 4 hours.

Remove from the oven, fish out the herb bundle and shred the meat from the bones into the sauce; discard bones and any large fat caps that haven’t melted into the sauce, along with any sinew or gristle. Skim the top layer of fat from the surface of the stew; you could have as much as a full cup. Add the vinegar and Worcestershire, then taste and add more salt and pepper if needed. Stir the frozen peas into the warm meat mixture and set aside while you make the topping. (Alternatively, you can chill the stew once the peas are added, and continue the recipe when ready to assemble the pie.)

Raise the oven temperature to 375°F.

For the topping, boil the potatoes and crushed garlic cloves in well salted water and drain when tender. Meanwhile, simmer the milk or half-and-half with the butter, bay leaf and sprig of thyme in a large pot. Drain the potatoes and garlic and add to the warm milk (removing the herbs) and mash with a fork until smooth (for a very smooth topping, press cooked potatoes and garlic through a potato ricer or food mill). Taste and add salt if needed, then stir in half the grated cheese and some black pepper to taste.

Fill a buttered oval gratin dish with the meat and top with dollops of the garlicky mashed potatoes, spread to cover and sprinkle with the remaining cheese. Bake until golden brown, about 35–40 minutes. Alternatively, divide the braised meat and vegetables between 6 small buttered casserole dishes arranged on a sheet tray. Top with potato and bake, 25–30 minutes or until browned on top.

Dress the bitter greens, parsley leaves and pickled shallots with the vinaigrette and serve.

This recipe appeared in the WInter 2027 issue as part of a larger story: New England Fare.