The Middle Way: A Delicate Balance Between Meat and Veg
Photos by Michael Piazza / Styled by Catrine Kelty
The arguments against eating meat make sense: the environmental, the moral and even the medical. But I’m afraid to admit that the arguments for eating meat make even more sense, which more often than not is what lands a double bacon cheeseburger in my hands. Caught between two opposing viewpoints, I’ve recently brought the Buddha into my kitchen. Central to Buddhist teachings is the idea of the middle way. Experiencing both indulgence and asceticism, the Buddha resolved to balance impulse and discipline, finding the freedom that comes with moderation.
Now, I’m not advocating that vegans eat a steak and carnivores eat a head of lettuce; I’m advocating for creative freedom in the kitchen, rethinking recipes, tinkering with textures and eating meat when I want to, not because I have to. Have to may be a strong choice of words, but what I’m talking about is not defaulting to eating meat, like thinking a meatball has to have meat in it, despite its name.
As the days grow shorter and colder, I’m drawn to soups, stews and yes, meat, with the feeling that vegetables alone can’t—and won’t—sustain me. But this winter, I’ll endeavor to live the middle way, to find balance in my kitchen and my diet.
Mentally, it feels like a big hurdle to pass on guanciale. When rendered perfectly in a Spaghetti Carbonara, the jowl of the pig becomes crispy, salty and addictive. However, I’ve tasted Spaghetti Carbonara, and I know it’s delicious, so why not try something new and exciting, like a sunchoke in place of the pork?
I’ll spoil my thesis: Meat does provide flavor, and lots of it, but so do other things. Sometimes, that new flavor is just what an old recipe needs. I love meatballs, especially when braised in a rich tomato sauce—and even cold from the fridge. So why would I swap mushrooms for the meat?
Because I cannot and will not give up on New England winter produce, despite the fact that, if I’m completely honest, it can be quite uninspiring. Winter produce, in seemingly every shade of brown, makes me miss the vibrancy of summer. But what is plentiful and delicious these days? Mushrooms, of course, and they’re available in all different shapes, sizes and personalities. I encourage you to head to a local farmers market or speciality shop on a mushroom hunt this season. On my own culinary journey to tackle the meatless meatballs, I settled on portobello and shiitake, which are not expensive or rare and full of umami, but you can use whatever mushroom variety you like best.
For all the swapping I’m doing this winter, I still find myself in the mood for a good steak—its flavor, char and bite. But in an effort to make it a more balanced meal, I’ve chosen to feature another favorite winter ingredient: radicchio, and in this middle way I’ve found a steak salad, naturally. I harnessed the bitterness of the radicchio, which is both its strength and its weakness if not handled properly; and the fatty, beefy notes of the steak and subtle sweetness of the honey, which play beautifully off each other. I am struck with a pleasant sense of satisfaction while eating this salad, having traded my usual steak accompaniment, frites, for something healthier, finding the middle way, and deciding to eat meat because I want to.
This story appeared in the Winter 2027 issue.